There have been many films lately that tackle the Iraq war. Some deal with the murky politics of the conflict, others deal with the cost on the home front in regards to the lives of soldiers and their families. But I don’t think any have combined those two things as elegantly as Stop Loss. Like her first film, Boys Don’t Cry, director Kimberly Peirce’s unflinching eye examines the emotional toll that results from a single act of defiance. In Boys it was the bold choice of Brendan Tenna to walk in his rightful shoes as a man. For Stop Loss’ Brendan King it’s also a matter of optics: does a volunteer soldier have any rights when his country needs him in a time of war?
King (Ryan Phillippe) returns to his small Texas town following a tour in Iraq that saw a number of his men killed or injured. The losses have an obvious emotional toll, but King, along with his friend Steve Shriver (Channing Tatum) are consoled by the thought they’re getting out of the army. However, King is caught by the army’s stop loss program, a clause that reserves the right of the armed forces to cease a soldiers discharge if they’re needed for the ongoing war effort. Based on a moral high ground, King believes he’s done his service and demands to be discharged. When he’s not, King goes AWOL and embarks on a cross country trek with Steve’s girlfriend Michelle (Abbie Cornish) to see his senator and request support.
A left wing bias is hard to argue when your main character is a US Army soldier that has served his country with distinction. His argument is more a matter of contractual obligation than an ideological point of view – the killing of civilians and such – although, that plays an important part too. On the one hand King is treated like a conquering hero, while on the other it can be argued he’s some kind of indentured servant; Peirce likes to play up both sides of this perspective that paints a vivid picture of the emotional hardship of being a soldier. You’re one relief overseas is the knowledge that one day your service will end and you can return home. Is it not a cruelty then to take those men, turn them around and send them back?
Aside from the administration of soldiers in a war, the film also looks at the psychological ramifications; none more prevalent than in the example of Tommy, a member of King’s unit, played by Joseph Gordon-Levitt. There’s always been a strong stigma against those with mental issues in the military or rather those that seek out help dealing with them. As the men arrive home on the bus, their roughneck CO (Timothy Olyphant) reminds them not to get into fights with civilians or hit their wives and kids while they’re on leave. It’s almost treated as a little injoke, but the fact of the matter that it’s deadly serious. Levitt’s devastating portrayal of an army man driven so mad by the ramifications of his vocation that he’s given a bad conduct discharge, is a movie in and of itself grounded in the actor’s exceptionally strong performance of quiet suffering.
Indeed, the entire cast is very strong. Phillippe plays both righteous and humble, strong though confused altogether in his portrayal of King. He doesn’t quite understand why he’s doing the things he does, but he knows that to accept the alternative is wrong; that what’s being done to him is wrong. Tatum is also very strong as Steve, who turns into Brendan’s opposite in the face of his friend’s actions, re-enlisting voluntarily in order to get the charges against King dropped. You get the feeling that Steve doesn’t believe just the same as King, but it occurs to him that he’s not capable of much outside an army uniform. To see how the suicide of a fellow soldier affects them and leads them into a final confrontation is a mean, emotional feat.
Lead by strong acting and a script that makes no easy decisions out a handful of horrible options, Stop Loss is powerful, personal filmmaking that takes the broader issues of the Iraq War and presents them in a relatable microcosm. It’s an affecting film with a number of strengths that make it one of the most compelling of the slate of recently released films on the subject. The end will leave you talking about the choices made and the choices you’d make, when it seems like the whole world is against you.


